from Fayetteville, NC
I've had these liners for about a month, and so far they have held up to my expectations, with a few small exceptions, which is why I rated it 4.5 rather than 5. I think the 2nd row liners would be more effective if they also covered farther under the front seats where adults have a tendency to stretch their feet into. Also the 1st row ends kind of early as well, it works perfect for the driver's seat, because you often don't put that seat back far, however my husband prefers to put the seat far back, and because of this he has about two to three inches that isn't protected by liner. Aside from that, I still feel like these liners were a great investment for my new car, and well worth the money.